A client recently asked me to write some “mini-white papers.”
Against my better judgement, I decided to try.
I agreed to write 10 mini-white papers of 2-3 pages each on an array of topics for a technology vendor. That’s less than half the length I normally write.
“Nobody reads long things any more,” I was assured by the 20-something marketer who contacted me.
I think what he really wanted—without knowing how to articulate it—was a set of short articles written by an SEO jockey to help build web traffic.
Based on my 20-20 hindsight from this recent experience, I’d like to dispel a few common myths about shorter white papers.
Mini-white paper myth #1:
A marketer can stretch their budget
If a 9-page white paper costs $7,500 then a three-pager should only cost $2,500. Right?
Not so fast.
No seasoned writer will happily reduce their fees in direction proportion to a shorter length.
There’s still research, interviewing, several drafts to create, rounds of comments to incorporate.
And remember: Writing shorter takes longer. Writing shorter involves extra edits to cut, compress and squeeze down the text to the desired brevity.
A client may be able to reduce their copy budget with an inexperienced writer… or as a one-time experiment with an experienced writer like myself.
But once bitten, twice shy. I’ll never again cut my fee in half to write a shorter white paper.
Mini-white paper myth #2:
A writer can save time
Each of those 10 mini-white papers was supposed to be about 50% the size of one of my regulars.
But when I totalled up my hours, each mini took me 80% of my regular effort to create.
I saved a little time, but not nearly as much as we projected. I really should have priced those minis at 80% of my regular fees.
The bottom line is that mini-white papers are not a great way for any client to save money… and not a great way for a writer to save time.
Mini-white paper myth #3:
Busy executives don’t read
Sure, it’s more “fun” to watch a 2-minute video than to read a 6-page document. But who says business is always supposed to be “fun”?
In a complex B2B sale, there’s a lot at stake: money, careers, maybe the future of the company.
A selection committee of high-level managers needs more than a video to support a decision. Those people need every vendor’s best arguments to compare and contrast, to weigh and measure, to analyze and debate.
A team making a costly decision requires narrative text that’s simple to annotate, to cut and paste into other documents, and to circulate up and down the corporate hierarchy.
That means they need a document. Not a video. Not a bunch of Tweets. Not reviews from someone you’ve never heard of before. A document.
Survey after survey for the past 20 years confirms that B2B buyers appreciate white papers.
In fact, according to a global study by content syndication firm Tech Target, white papers are the most popular content for B2B technology buyers in all these countries: Australia, France, India, Italy, New Zealand, South Africa, UK, and USA.
Who is it that doesn’t read any more?
Mini-white paper myth #4:
Shorter is better
By definition, a mini-white paper contains less information, less advice, and fewer insights. That means a mini just doesn’t have enough space to present an in-depth discussion.
By necessity, a mini often devolves back to more of a brochure—a product description in a thin wrapper of content —instead of providing the rich educational detail of a full-fledged white paper.
A 2- or 3-page white paper is simply too short to present much research or logical argument. And 0fter all, a full-length white paper already has a built-in mini-version: the executive summary.
This one-page précis of the key ideas can be scanned in less than a minute by anyone, no matter how busy. Then they can decide whether to invest any more time to read the full-length document.
Mini-white paper myth #5:
You can say everything in 2 or 3 pages
I didn’t want to deliver watered-down brochure copy to my client.
So I squeezed references, tables, an introduction, conclusions, and a call to action into each of my minis. But that made them longer.
Our 10 minis totalled 38 pages, for an average length of about 3.75 pages. But that’s effectively 4 pages. And each had a full-page cover, which made the average mini-white paper 5 pages long.
That’s twice as long as the projected 2 or 3 pages!
Hmmm… looks like you really can’t cover everything in 2 or 3 pages.
Mini-white paper myth #6:
The future is here. Rich media rules!
The Millennials born from 1985 on have grown up with mobile technology and social networks.
Surveys and anecdotal observations shows that many Millennials prefer to interact or watch video rather than read text.
Certainly marketing needs to evolve to satisfy them. And the economy will change as Millennials start making decisions about purchasing big, complex products for companies.
But since the oldest Millennials are just over 30, they’re still a good 10 years away from becoming chief decision-makers in most companies.
The future isn’t here yet.
The bottom line on mini-white papers:
Know your audience
But who cares what *you or I* think? The only person whose opinion really matters is your intended prospect.
The first rule of marketing still applies: Know your audience.
If you sell to companies run by young hipsters, maybe you do need shorter and more entertaining content than a 6 to 8-page white paper.
But if you sell to medium and large enterprises, not so much.
If your target reader is a typical C-level executive, they didn’t get to where they are by watching YouTube. They’re probably 40 to 60 years old, and they got there in large part by reading, thinking, and debating.
If your competitors have full-length white papers with enough substance for prospects to sink their teeth into, and you don’t… guess who loses the sale?
So next time you’re tempted to do a mini-white paper, think carefully.
Do you really buy into these myths? Is it really wise to cut the length of a white paper… if that’s going to reduce its impact and lose sales?
Have you ever written (or sponsored) a mini-white paper? How well did that work for the company? Please leave your comments below.