White papers versus brochures
White papers and brochures are almost complete opposites.
Back in the day, every B2B vendor printed up glossy brochures for every major product. These were handed out at trade shows, left behind after sales calls, and even mailed out to prospects: all to create interest and desire.
An effective brochure pushed “emotional buttons” such as fear, greed, envy or vanity. They were generally colorful, flashy and filled with promises.
These days, about the only place I still see brochures is in car dealerships.
Everywhere else, printed brochures have evolved into salesy product webpages. Different format, same approach: sell the dream.
White papers, on the other hand, are persuasive essays that appeal more to logic. A good white paper is more informative, substantial and dignified than any brochure or product page.
If it’s plain, it’s a keeper
Some self-styled marketing “experts” urge vendors to make their white papers as flashy as brochures. This is nonsense.
A white paper should look much plainer. Making it look like a sales piece is the kiss of death for a white paper.
There’s a time-honored ritual many IT people do when they get home from a trade show:
- Sort through the pile of vendor materials
- Get rid of anything that looks too flashy
- Keep anything that looks plainer and more informative
Guess which pile the brochures go into?
The key differences
In any case, this table sums up the key differences I can see between a brochure and a white paper.
about a product
|New solution to an
old problem, or
benefits of some
product or service
|Here's a better way
to solve this problem
|Length||2 to 4 pages||5 to 12 pages|
|Format||Slicker: lots of |
|Plainer: PDF with
good design and
a few graphics
|Lifespan||Until the product|
|1 or 2 years,
|Time to create||4 to 12 weeks||4 to 12 weeks|
|When to use||Whenever you want|
to "sell the dream"
|Whenever you want
to provide useful
|Why to use||A sales pitch to |
|To generate leads,
or explain product
Never pretend a brochure is a white paper
Some marketers are tempted to reformat a brochure and call it a “white paper.”
This is a silly waste of time that can easily blow up in your face. That’s because no one who downloads a white paper is looking for a sales pitch.
Most readers become quite irritated when they see that a vendor has renamed a brochure as a white paper. Some will be so disgusted they take that vendor off their shortlist.
Combine a brochure with a datasheet
A more useful approach is to combine a brochure with a datasheet.
You can devote the front and middle pages to the dreamy copy of the brochure, then use the back page to list all the technical specifications, modules or system requirements of the product.
This gives both some emotional appeal, and the factual details about the product, all in one document.
Do you even need brochures?
To my mind, it’s debatable whether printed brochures even count as “content.”
I’d call them more like “advertising.”
And if your budget is tight, you can probably eliminate them entirely.
I believe nearly all B2B vendors will get better results from investing in white papers and case studies.
At an event like a trade show, you can collect business cards in exchange for a well-executed white paper or some compelling case studies. These will likely generate more interest and credibility than yet another brochure or salesy webpage.
Want to hear whenever there’s a fresh article on this site? Subscribe here to stay in the know on long-form content. From time to time, we’ll also send you word about some great new resource or training. And you can unsubscribe any time.
[…] https://thatwhitepaperguy.com/white-paper-planning/white-papers-versus-brochures/ […]
[…] Graham, G. (2017). White papers versus brochures | That White Paper Guy – Gordon Graham. Available at: https://thatwhitepaperguy.com/white-paper-planning/white-papers-versus-brochures/. […]