Skip to content

To gate or not to gate?

That is the question, for anyone involved in content marketing today.

So what’s the best answer?

As you know, “gated content” is a white paper, special report, or any other content you give to a site visitor after they complete a registration form.

We’ve all filled in those forms. But do they work?

 

A dirty little secret of content marketing

Not everyone tells the truth on registration forms.

For example, one survey done by MarketingSherpa found that about 7 out of 10 prospects give their true name. But less than 6 out of 10 give their real industry, company name, or job title. And less than 4 out of 10 give their actual phone number.

I’ve filled in some forms with names like “Donald Duck” and phone numbers like “123-456-7890.” Haven’t you?

Especially when the form is way too long.

Beyond that, many business people have a free e-mail account at Yahoo or Google to use only for content downloads. The rest of the time, they ignore those accounts.

Despite these issues, most B2B vendors used to routinely hide their white papers behind gates.

20X to 50X more downloads?!

At least they did until 2009. That’s when marketing guru and author David Meerman Scott made quite the splash.

He claimed that a white paper or e-book would be downloaded 20 to 50 times more often if there was no gate in front of it.

Consider what this means for lead-generation, as shown in the following table.

Ungated Content Gated Content Ratio
Visitors to landing page 120 120 1:1
How many download? 60 12 5:1
How many read? 30 6 5:1
How many pass along? 15 3 5:1
Total prospects reached 45 9 5:1

This table uses relatively conservative assumptions:

  • Ungated content is downloaded 5X as often
  • Half those who download content read it
  • Half of those who read content pass it along

Of course, your mileage may vary.

If you’re in a position to do some testing and capture these metrics for your content campaigns, why not give it a try?

Then you can see for yourself what difference it makes to gate or not to gate.

What do you want to accomplish?

The problem with most discussions about gating is that they don’t start at square one: your purpose for creating content in the first place.

There are two main purposes for creating content:

  1. To generate leads
  2. To get noticed

This is where the discussion should start at your organization. Depending on your goals, you can quickly decide whether to gate your content, or not.

Trying to generate leads?

If you want to generate leads and develop prospects, you’re going to need contact info to stay in touch.

So for generating leads, you need a registration form.

I’ve said it before: Keep the form simple. Maybe four fields in all: name, work e-mail, company, and title. And be thankful if you get honest answers to all four!

Trying to get noticed?

If you want to get your company noticed, you want as many people as possible reading and sharing your work. So take down that gate!

This is especially true for startups, and for any B2B firm waging a marketing campaign against an entrenched incumbent.

After all, they’re probably already on the shortlist of vendors to check out. Your goal is to get your firm noticed, so it’s in the running too.

Remember what makes content valuable

The most valuable B2B content helps a business person understand an issue, solve a problem, or make a decision. If your content consistently does that, prospects won’t mind giving you some contact information.

When you give a business person something valuable, they know you’re going to try to develop them as customers. They’re ready for that.

So don’t be too shy to ask.

For more on this issue, see our article “Gating: the third option.” 

 


What works best for your company? Share your thoughts in the Comments section.

About Gordon Graham

Author of close to 300 white papers on everything from choosing enterprise software to designing virtual worlds for kids, for clients from Silicon Valley to Switzerland, from tiny startups to 3M, Google and Verizon. Also wrote White Papers for Dummies which earned 50 5-star ratings on Amazon. And Gordon was recently named 2019 Copywriter of the Year by AWAI.

If you liked this post...

Magnifier Glass Over The Red Inscription Writer Cut Out Of Paper

8 reasons to hire a white paper writer who knows your industry

Some say that the best white paper writers are generalists who can write about any...
Outside writer vs in-house writer

5 good reasons to hire an outside white paper writer

You've come up with a brilliant idea for a white paper. It’s so good, it...
book and laptop with many flags to symbolize translation

5 things you must know about translating white papers

  Do you ever prepare a white paper for readers who use a different language?...

5 Comments

  1. Eric on October 8, 2014 at 4:40 pm

    As a CIO, I almost always give bogus contact information when I fill out one of those gate forms. I learned early on what happens when you tell the truth. You get flooded with calls from people who can barely speak English asking you to attend their webinar or worse – reading you a list of mutiple choice questions to qualify you.

    Rrrrrring…
    Me: “Eric Lynch, speaking”

    Caller: “eh-lo, Edeek, this is Srinivas fdom ABC123 Company. How you doeeng to-deh?”

    Me: Click

  2. Stephanie Tilton (@StephanieTilton) on October 8, 2014 at 5:19 pm

    Great post, Gordon! The decision to gate or not to gate seems to not be a decision at all in many cases. In other words, it seems the default is often “we worked hard on this paper and we sure aren’t going to just give it away for free!” In other words, some companies think the value of the paper is tied to their effort to produce it.

    I like your suggestion to start by determining your goal (leads or awareness). And I’d take it a step further and suggest B2B marketers need to map their white papers to the buying cycle. Prospective buyers early in the cycle are less likely to exchange their info for a download. Why reduce the number of potential buyers so early on? Have a bit of patience and deliver enough valuable content and prospects are usually willing to share their info.

  3. Dan Davis on October 8, 2014 at 6:46 pm

    Hey Gordon;

    This topic is perfectly timed; I’ve been wrestling with the “gate/no gate” question for a bit. As of this post, I have decided on the following:

    I propose–and employ–an “end gate philosophy” in the following manner;

    1) Start (TOFU) Gate-Free to Get Noticed

    All of my online content is gate free, with one exception, noted below.

    The reason?

    Throughput from source (me) to a prospective client is direct, simple, and anonymously accessible. In theory (and the data supports this), more people are going to initially read–and disseminate–my material. In short, “free” stuff supports further engagement.

    Ideally, they will effortlessly drift farther down the gate-free funnel, leading to 2)…

    2) Gate “Valid” Prospects for Lead-Gen

    My rates are accessible only through a gate. Simply put, if someone has reviewed my un-gated material, and is interested enough to find out how much I cost, then they’re probably in need of my services. At this point, I want to know their email address and make them my newest pals.

    This potentially saves substantial time pursuing “lookie-loo’s” that may pass through an earlier “top-of-funnel” gate.

    As you mentioned Gordon, with content you’ve given a prospect something valuable and–at that point–they can expect to provide contact information. I think this “one-two” combination may work in concert with that notion.

    Keep in mind however, this is only a personal theory. It could crash and burn.

    Thanks again for the insightful article!
    Dan

  4. Alan on October 9, 2014 at 11:12 am

    Very interesting and relevant information. Thank you for sharing!

  5. Michael Shearer (@michaelshearer) on October 9, 2014 at 4:29 pm

    If you are not going to gate, make strong calls to action in the content you’re giving away. If you are going to gate, try progressive profiling (available through good marketing automation tools, like Net-Results), where you start with a very simple gate (First Name and Email or just Email, even). Every time someone re-visits your site to get new content that has previously opted-in will have 1 or 2 basic questions to answer that vary from previously completed form fills. This way you are building a prospects profile to help figure out who they are and how you can best help them.

Leave a Comment